Animation Domination: "The Tenth Planet" Animated Episode 4 Review
By Greg Bakun
Although The Tenth Planet is 47 years old, I appreciate not everyone has seen it and is waiting for the DVD to come out. Please note that this article reveals some plot points and spoilers that may ruin the enjoyment of the episode/story. If you do not want to be spoiled please do not read further or read at your own risk.
It is a well-established fact that The Tenth Planet is one of my favourite
stories of Doctor Who. I am a
massive fan of the Cybermen and I am a massive fan of the Innes Lloyd/Gerry
Davis era of Doctor Who. When I get
around to writing a 50WHO article on the first Doctor, I will focus that
article on The Tenth Planet and why I
love it. This article is to look at something different; something I never
expected to see in my lifetime, an animated Episode 4 of The Tenth Planet.
The full bells & whistle release of The Tenth Planet will be released as a
2-Disc DVD set in November. Not only will we get all four episodes but a host
of other extras. It is a release I am really excited to get in my hands. On
June 24th, the BBC in the UK will release a 6 DVD boxset simply
titled Doctor Who: Regeneration. This
boxset has the final story of each Doctor. To be more accurate, it will focus on
the story the Doctor regenerates in. This is unfortunate for the likes of Colin
Baker who shows up at the very end of The
Caves of Androzani and is played by Sylvester McCoy at the very beginning
of Time and the Rani. In fact,
Sylvester McCoy basically regenerates into himself. What I am going to focus on
are the four (out of nine) episodes of Disc 1. To be more accurate, I am just
focusing on one of the episodes.
As fans of Doctor Who on DVD, we have simply been blessed and this year in
particular has been pretty sweet. We have seen a steady release of stories
re-released as Special Editions. The picture on these have been vastly improved
which is very important to me. Inferno
is a great example of this. One of the most amazing releases I could ever hope
for was a full colour version of The Mind
of Evil. I dreamed of such things as a child but that truly was fantasy and
now it is a reality. I have probably watched it about 10 times since it was
released. Why? Maybe I am afraid I will wake up and it was all just a dream
after all. Something else we got was a dream for many fans….missing episode animations.
In 2006, we got the release of The Invasion with the animation work for
Episodes 1 & 4 going to Cosgrove Hall. It was really good and was a lot of
fun to watch these episodes "move". I think my favourite part of
these animations were the backgrounds. They looked great. Often they were
photos from the actual sets and given a treatment so they could blend better
with the animated characters. After The
Invasion, animated versions of missing episodes seemed to have died. Slowly
word started to spread that more episodes would come on the horizon and I think
the choice that was made to restart this was perhaps a little surprising.
In January of 2013 the BBC released The Reign of Terror with The Tyrant of France and A Bargain of Necessity animated by
Thetamation which is now Planet 55. I was not a huge fan of the animation for
various reasons. To sum it up, the pacing and energy of the story did not match
the episodes around it. I thought that was a problem. There were too many
extreme close-ups that are anachronistic to how the episodes were originally made.
I felt that the character designs were inconsistent and varied greatly from
shot to shot. To find out that Planet 55 was going to animate the final episode
of my favourite story worried me.
The
Tenth Planet on the Regeneration
set has been fully restored. I had thought about jumping straight to the
animated episode but the clarity of the other 3 episodes caught my eye. The
films always looked in rough shape but here a lot of work had gone into it.
Remember, for Episodes 1 & 2 16mm negatives exist and for Episode 3 only a
16mm positive print exists which, according to Wiped!, a 16mm duplicate film
negative was made from this print. The funny thing is I could tell that Episode
3 was lesser quality than the previous 2 episodes. That being said, it all
looks good. I could see it before, but the VIDfire on the episodes really shows
up the eyes in the Cybermen costumes. It is a fantastic feature of this
earliest version of the Cybermen. I love all Cybermen but what they are here is
really true to their concept. They really are corpses being kept alive through
artificial means and their planet Mondas.
I will go into more detail of the first
3 episodes at a later date but the real question is, how did Planet 55 do on
animating Episode 4 of The Tenth Planet? I think there is a
significant improvement over the two episodes of The Reign of Terror. Is it perfect? No but it's good enough to
actually complete the story for me.
As I mentioned above, there are 9
episodes on Disc 1. Yes, 9 Episodes. That is a lot of content. Episodes 1-3
look great but Episode 4 starts off
with a very compressed opening credits. There are a lot of artifact gradients
in it. I was wondering if it was going to affect the rest of the episode but it
didn't. To me, it looks like Episode 4 was given the lowest bit-rate on the
disc because it is animation.
Unlike the two episodes of The Reign of Terror, I feel that this
animation is more sympathetic to the flow of the rest of the story. I love the
direction of Derek Martinus. All you need to do is see some of the crane shots
he employs in Galaxy Four: Airlock
and it is easy to see how imaginative of a director he was for the series. The
animation employs shots like those too. There are shots looking down on the
Cybermen and other characters of the Snowcap control room. Perhaps it was a
little high up of a shot for a 1960s television production but I don't care
because it looks great. It's a shot that Derek Martinus would try and achieve.
It never feels out of place for me.
I have read one comment from someone who
says that Planet 55 doesn't know how to direct an episode because character's
faces get cut-off on screen. I disagree. There are some great half face shots
of the Cybermen that are chilling and look really atmospheric. No, shots like
that were not originally done on The
Tenth Planet with the Cybermen but it still does not look out of place
here. There is a shot of Hartnell where he takes up the whole screen but we
know that is exactly how it looked from the actual episode as we see it in the
8mm clips. Even in The Tomb of the
Cybermen, the cliffhanger for Episode
2 is an extreme close-up of the Cybercontroller. It takes up most of the
screen and it looks great so there is precedent for that. This is a very stark
turnaround from The Reign of Terror
as the close-ups in those episodes were just bizarre. I can also report there
are no crotch shots in Episode 4 of The Tenth Planet unlike The Reign of Terror.
The animation helps explains the story
for me better than ever before when I watched it. It just goes to show how visual
of a person I am. I watched this with my friend Robert who was part of a team
who did brilliant reconstructions and even he felt some plot points were made
clearer from this animated version. I thought the scene at the beginning of the
episode with Cutler threatening to kill the Doctor, Ben, Polly and Barclay was
very tense. While he is threatening to kill them, his technicians are warning
him that the Cybermen have returned in their spaceship and are approaching the
base. Cutler ignores them and up until they return, the action continues to
escalate resulting in Cutler's death. I really thought that was well-done. I
love the scene with Geneva calling Snowcap with the Doctor answering. The
episode is bleak and tense yet we have this wonderful scene proving to us all,
once again, that William Hartnell could do brilliant comedy one last time for
the series. Finally, when the Cybermen make one final push to get Ben, Barclay
and Dyson out of the chamber where they are working on the Z bomb, the Cybermen
are going to gas them. I have seen the reconstruction many times plus listened
to the audio but it never hit me that they were going to gas them. It is great
and the scene before with the Cybermen in the control room planning their
strategy, one has a gas container attached to its back. It's really brilliant
stuff.
This is a very straight forward
presentation of the episode which is what I wanted to see. Maybe a little too
straight forward since every off-hand sound has a visual such as a wrench being
nudged. That's hardly a big deal at all. It's really nice to see movement to
scenes I have always wanted to experience. This includes when the Doctor leaves
the Cybership to go back to the TARDIS. Before he leaves, he softly tells his
two companions to "keep warm". There is no music or sounds to
accompany this scene. It is just a sweet moment and I feel like William
Hartnell is telling all of us that. It's his final goodbye to us the viewer.
There are a lot of visual questions answered or at least addressed in this
episode that I will let you see for yourself such as how they deal with the
destruction of Mondas.
Here are some comparison shots between
the telesnaps and how Planet 55 realised those shots:
The improvement between The Reign of Terror and The
Tenth Planet is immense. After I saw the animation for The Reign of Terror, I didn't want these guys to touch Doctor Who again. Now, with the Tenth Planet Episode 4, the character
designs are great. The way they handled the clothed-faced Cybermen is perfect
and I am not disappointed at all. I am a fan and I look forward to what they
have for us next! To paraphrase a wonderful character in this episode, in terms
of Planet 55 animating more Doctor Who,
I really hope it is "far from being all over!" OK, that was cheesy.
Greg Bakun is a huge British television collector and enthusiast. He randomly picks programs to watch and writes about them for his site, From the Archive: A British Television Blog (www.from-the-archive.co.uk). He writes about all kinds of British television, from Ace of Wands to Z Cars, plus a lot of Doctor Who. You can follow updates to his blog on Twitter @FromtheArchive.
Labels: Doctor Who, Greg Bakun, Guest Blog, reviews
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home